Halloween Cakes, Because We Need More Sugary Treats


Sometimes helpful editor and digital media director at MAKE and CRAFT.

179 Articles

By shawnconna

Sometimes helpful editor and digital media director at MAKE and CRAFT.

179 Articles

I’m not sure who decided that Halloween cupcakes, cookies, and regular-sized cakes were a good idea for Halloween, but I’m not the one to buck tradition, especially when it involves frosting. And creative decorating.

dirt_cake_small.jpg graveyard_cake_small.jpg

So over the years I’ve made quite a few graveyard cakes, and in recent years I’ve branched out to spider cakes, ghost cakes, jack-o-lantern cakes, and dirt cakes. I do, however, refuse to make a litter box cake, no matter how many times I get sent the photos, links, and recipe. Apparently, imitation cat poop is where I draw the line.
Ive figured out that donating the majority of the cakes to the local Halloween Carnival helps reduce sugar consumption. Well, until my kid wins a cake in the cakewalk and brings it back home. But at least I tried!

spidercake_small.jpg spidercake2_small.jpg

Here are some hints for making fabulous Halloween cakes, if you dare!

  • For glowing eyes on the Ghost Cake, use halves of egg shells, rinsed off and dried. Then place a sugar cube in each half of the shell, poor a very small amount of lemon extract on the sugar cubes, and light that sucker. Don’t leave this unattended!
  • For the ghosts on the Graveyard Cake, I’ve used cut-and-slice cookie dough, cut out sugar cookies, and lollipops wrapped in white cloth. Whatever you’ve got around will suffice.
  • For legs on the Spider Cake, find some Pockys, which are delicious cookies from Japan. I’ve found them at Cost Plus and specialty grocery stores. I also thought Pirouette wafers might work, or maybe even Twix bars.
  • For all the cakes, don’t be afraid to substitute Skittles for M&Ms for Reeses Pieces for Gummy Bears. Most anything will work when seen in context — you’re bound to hear “Oh, those are the spider’s eyes,” or “Oh, little bears are lining the walkway, how spooky!” (As opposed to, “Why did you use Skittles instead of M&Ms? That doesn’t work at all!”)