Find all your DIY electronics in the MakerShed. 3D Printing, Kits, Arduino, Raspberry Pi, Books & more!

What would the trunk of a tree sound like if a cross section of it were played like an LP? With his creation Years, Bartholomäus Traubeck attempts to answer that question by using a turntable, PlayStation Eye Camera, a stepper motor to control the arm, and computer running Ableton Live. As you’ll hear in the video above, the rings of the tree trunk, as interpreted by this piece, create an eerie and ominous piano track that sounds like it was taken from psychological horror film. Who knew trees were so emo? [via Creative Applications]

Matt Richardson

Matt Richardson

Matt Richardson is a Brooklyn-based creative technologist, Contributing Editor at MAKE, and Resident Research Fellow at New York University’s Interactive Telecommunications Program (ITP). He’s the co-author of Getting Started with Raspberry Pi and the author of Getting Started with BeagleBone.


Related

Comments

  1. critical says:

    Deceptive article. The rings are not creating an “eerie ominous piano track”. At most, Bartholomäus Traubeck is creating a piano sounding track using software to interpret raw noise. The noise itself does not naturally sound like a piano.

    1. Matt Richardson says:

      Thanks for the feedback. I didn’t mean for the text to be how you’ve interpreted it (as I know the rings don’t sound like a piano). I’ll try rewording it to make it more clear. Thanks again.

      1. Rick says:

        Hy Matt can you make some with nylon string/classical guitar sound i thank it grate to hear what Mother Nature has to say about music.and it was beautiful.Rick

    2. NigNog says:

      No fucking shit.

      1. Dumbass doesn't understand what shouldn't have to be stated. says:

        What a fucking dumbass.

      2. johnkeojon says:

        Nig Nog keep your filthy language to yourself!

        1. patrickfelony says:

          yo i made up the phrase nig nog! touche sir.. only shows that there is another genius like me in the world :D

    3. Duh says:

      Your failure to understand something obvious does not make this article deceptive. It’s fairly common knowledge that trees do not sound like pianos. I guess you were sick the day they taught that one, huh.

      1. David says:

        Trees do eventually sound like pianos, after you cut them down and make them into pianos! They also sound like guitars, basses and some woodwind instruments.

        I understand how all this stuff works, so I want to comment that the slice of tree trunk is not really doing anything here but triggering preset chords in Ableton Live. Its only the light and dark areas, like the knot, that are doing anything. The chords could have been changed to something less dramatic sounding, or to anything at all.

        So while this is kind of interesting, there is no real data coming from the tree and being turned into notes. You can do this with images of things, by interpreting the pixel data, but that’s not what’s being done here.

        By the same token you can place a round photograph of anything on that turntable and get almost the exact same affect.

        So I have to agree that it’s kind of a gimmick. The fact that it’s being presented as performance art makes it even more so.

        1. David says:

          Wow, Dave, great point. I feel like less of a David now, thanks.

          1. Thomas says:

            I had to reply just because your comment made me lol haha :)

          2. Rami says:

            You guys really made my day … the First David was so serious and informative, in contrary the second David broke all the ambiance into something silly but funny…

    4. Erik says:

      Thanks, Captain Obvious. I’ll bet you’re the smartest guy in your trailer park.
      Go back to your “Dukes of Hazzard” re-runs.

      1. mark says:

        He’s busy getting out the vote for yer boy O-blame-a

    5. i have to agree with critical – the attached video is NOT of a tree trunk being ‘played like a record’ because the mechanics of a record are the minute variations in the grooves cause DIRECT vibrations in the air (ie sound)

      this video is of a PC interpreting non-random source of data and has obviously been heavily tweaked to sound acceptable to westerm music trained ears

      frankly, i’m dissapointed – i wanted to hear a tree trunk with as little intermediary as possible

      1. Henry says:

        But that would be bizarre, static-y, white noise that resembles nothing more than sand-paper dragging on gravel.

      2. Duh says:

        Go put your ear up to a fucking tree trunk then

      3. Keith Kurman says:

        then perhaps you should try doing your own piece rather than projecting your undeveloped musings onto someone eles’s work. it wouldn’t then be an original idea, of course, but that would be in keeping with your rather empty comment on the piece itself.

      4. Madison says:

        I agree with you. This is lame. If there were any decipherable information in the tree that could be converted into sound, it sure would not sound like that. If anything, that absolute only correlation between what we hear and the tree is the rhythm, considering everything else is completely altered

    6. Wow. Talk about over-analysis.

      1. Marcus Henderson says:

        this was not what i expected when i hit stumble.

      2. ninjassin says:

        Me either lol

    7. dustin says:

      on top of that, on a musical note, everything on this is in the tune of something, if they really matched notes up with what the tree said, it would be like a kid hitting as many buttons as he could at the same time, this is set to some kind of note-set. at that rate, they might as well have faked the whole thing

    8. sammboy says:

      so? at least it sounds cool, regardless of what is actually happening. and since you know what’s happening, what would it sound like if it were actually playing like an lp?

  2. ruth nix says:

    I think marimba or log drum something made of wood

  3. Jeanne Cermak says:

    Turn that off, you’ll attract Ents

    1. MJ says:

      great comment! love it … ;-)

    2. nikki says:

      hehehehehe the ents will be after revenge! first you’ve killed their family now you’re playing with the corpse! hehehe :D :D

  4. umamimusic says:

    Fun! Also – I suspect that they are using not just Ableton Live, but Cycling 74′s Max (an object-oriented audio/video/MIDI language which integrates directly with Live) to translate the video signal to MIDI and play the sounds. Max is a great tool, and this looks like a brilliant use.

    1. mja says:

      says it wsa done in vvvv on the site. oretty similar to Max/Msp

  5. yves says:

    Really cool
    How does it decide what notes to play?
    is it where the lines are and how thick they are?
    Or does it just detect color variation?

    either way very cool.

  6. [...] pointed this out to me this morning. Yes, those are the rings of a tree trunk being used to procedurally [...]

  7. I know that thicker tree rings tell us that the tree grew more that year as opposed to thinner rings where there was slower growth. Soo when I’m hearing more activity in this “song”, can I assume that it is playing a thicker ring? Or are the increased noises more of a reflection of when the lines are reallyclosetogether? Either way, it’s super cool to hear the story of the tree’s life.

    1. Chris Holden says:

      What a great interpretation – I just thought “cool, control midi with some unusual media” but you’ve made a great point. I’m still learning to appreciate “art” in all it’s forms, but to think about how the tree grew to create the different rings (and thus the different sounds) creates quite a different listening experience!

  8. Maezeppa says:

    In a similar vein (ha ha) http://bit.ly/logblammo

  9. I’m tired of these data as sound projects. The way the data in interpolated is programmed and controlled by a human. It’s just a gimmick. Get over it.

    1. brucerhee says:

      i’m tired of grumpy ass fools who feel compelled to shit on something many people happen to find novelty in and appreciate. i hope your comment made you feel better about your miserable self, because really, if shitting on the creative works of others and trivializing it to the point of douchbaggery is what gets you off, you my sad friend are a pathetic loser that needs to get laid or rip a bongload. something.

      1. Jordan says:

        Wow, someone can’t take any criticism whatsoever. Yikes! Good luck with that.

      2. J says:

        I like the way that what started as a project that someone decided they would share with the world for those who would appreciate it, something with a completely good intention the expression of self through art has become a huge bitch fest of people on both sides. It really does say something about the world, if you didn’t like it oh well move on, your life has in no way been altered. If you listened and fell in love with a new beautiful peace of art congrats but don’t gratify those who seek attention by giving it to them. I mean really you took art, whether you enjoyed it or not, and turned it into a distorted babbling of hate. I’m 18 and even I can see how fucked up that is. I don’t know how the software works I don’t know if the story is BS or not but I could care less ill base the beauty from the content and let the music speak for itself.

        1. Invader Vin says:

          Very nicely stated J. The fact that you’re 18 gives me some hope in what I otherwise deem a hopeless generation. Unfortunately, the amazing technologies that have developed in the past twenty years have created a kind of democratization of opinion that shows how oppressive free speech can be, and engenders the kind of rampant narcissicism that thrives in tweets and blogs and fecesbook. Oh yeah, I meant facebook, but it’s all the same to these kids who don’t know how to spell, no nothing about art or life, and yet deem their opinions worth sharing. Sorry folks, but there is a difference between opinion and criticism. Everyone has an opinion, and opinions are of equal value, that value being nada.

    2. kat says:

      “The way the data in interpolated is programmed and controlled by a human. It’s just a gimmick.”

      I call troll, just based on how little sense this criticism makes.

    3. Mike says:

      The fact that you called it a gimmick just proves how invalid your comment was. A gimmicks intent is to trick or deceive you into taking something that’s offered with little promise of return. Whatever this person provided, they delivered. They wanted to hear what a tree trunk sounded like as if it were a record, and they did just that. Even if for the purpose of exploiting technology, this is awesome. The fact they used a Playstation Eye Camera alone makes this a cool project. Try doing that in the 70′s when that type of technology didn’t exist.

      1. Duane says:

        The fact remains, the amount of effort that went into this validates the findings, at the end of the day the tree rings was converted to midi patterns and played with a piano, it could just as easy have been any other instrument but the piano sounded the best. try to appreciate the pure awesomeness of the project.

        Haters gonna hate!!!

        big up to the guys who made this happen!

  10. [...] WordPress.org Link: Music: Tree Ring Cross Section Played Through Piano If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!Bartholomäus Traubeck recently played a tree’s cross section’s thin section on a turntable, using a variety of computer gear to transfer the sound to a piano track. The result is actually pretty nice, somewhat eerie, and not as random as you’d think. Read more about the work and listen to a thin section (it is a couple of minutes) by pressing this link to the Make post: http://blog.makezine.com/2012/01/19/play-the-rings-of-a-tree-trunk-like-a-record/. [...]

  11. [...] riddle as we’re ever going to get. [Bartholomäus Traubeck via Creative Applications via Make] artMusicclipsGeek Out  Discuss  Share  Tweet  Email  More [...]

  12. [...] from Makezine.com. Very cool idea but would also like to hear what it sounds like without the piano sounds added to [...]

  13. Dfarmergirl says:

    What kind of tree?

  14. mstruck says:

    Play the rings from inside out. This way we hear the sapling grow into the mighty tree!

    1. Whitney says:

      That would be awesome, too! More intense at first, then more peaceful as it ages!

  15. Whitney says:

    I. love. this. I think I need more.

  16. Nikola Tesla says:

    Hey there brucer!!, I am in copletagreeamobility with your vibes/reverbs towards grandpa Munster but, dont let his “aditune” get the beast of you to be ensure.

  17. Scott says:

    Considering that a tree grows from its center outward, I would think the tree is being played backwards. It should be played as it was “recorded” – from the center most track, CCW to the outermost.

  18. twentyone&½ says:

    Reblogged this on Twentyoneandahalf and commented:
    Es impresionante como la tecnología y la naturaleza se combinan.

  19. [...] 5 bloggers like this post. Like this: What would the trunk of a tree sound like if a cross section of it were played like an LP? MAKE | Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record – StumbleUpon [...]

  20. A. Bastard says:

    lame

  21. mikey says:

    that isn’t going on my record player, the damn cartridge cost me $150!

  22. [...] MAKE What would the trunk of a tree sound like if a cross section of it were played like an LP? With his [...]

  23. adfadfa says:

    It’s only emo sounding because the program is set to that minor chord. Throw in a few majors and bump up the tempo and that tree will rock out for sure. Besides, everything’s funnier in fast motion.

    1. Gabe says:

      Maybe it’s emo because it’s a… weeping willow

  24. Amazing interpretation… isn’t that what all music, even all sound is? We record certain tones, filter out others, mix this part higher or lower.. change or emphasize a chord… it doesn’t make it any less ‘true’ a sound to the person that created it.. everything we ‘hear’ is in one way or another an interpretation albeit just our own.

  25. Tib says:

    I work with wood every day, and I really, really enjoyed this. There is a visual rhythm to grain, and it was wonderful to see that pattern interpreted as sound. I wonder if the measurements from a densitometer could translate to sound, too.
    Thank you for giving me yet another way to think about this wonderful material!
    Tib Shaw
    AAW Gallery of Wood Art

    1. yeah, im that guy says:

      I think its hot that you work with wood everyday.

  26. slkfajsdf says:

    this is plain stupid

  27. Technopsis says:

    A nice little piece of art. Of course this is quite different from actually playing a piece of log like an LP, but still the idea is very cool!

  28. Emilio says:

    i do not believe this tree is being played exactly like a record, but it could work in a similar way. in the describtion he says he used a playstation camera, rather than a needle like on a record player. the camera could be catching the image of the rings and the computer matching the position of the rings to a note on a music staff. in that case the tree wouldnt play the music but rather have music printed on it.

  29. allen derico says:

    This is what happens when people have way too much free time.

  30. louise ann says:

    This beyond me! I love cool things that are beyond me. Thanks for sharing this artful brilliance. Louise Ann

  31. Sue H says:

    However, pianos are made from trees, so….

  32. Paul says:

    Or, the artist was culturally disposed to decide, whether he thought he was or not, to come up with a dramatic, if gloomy, piece. It wouldn’t be very convincing if a tree that had stood for decades came out with something that sounded like “M-I-C K-E-Y m o u s e” or Justin Bieber, now would it?

    A good way to prove this is to have people of different ages, and from different cultures, with the same technical expertise set up the same experiment and see what they come up with.

  33. Keith Kurman says:

    a wonderful piece. great idea skillfully developed. I’ve considered something like this in the deep past but dismissed it as impractical, we didn’t have this technology back in the iron age of SIM, not that I wood (sic.) have drawn the same conclusions. I love the aesthetics of it, simple, clear and to the point. the optical tracking is an ingenious solution, of course, tree rings are not spirally arranged, they are concentric, but irregular, so capturing that irregularity is down-right Cage-ian, The irony of the knot. As I might say to any of my hyper-creative friends, ” Do a hundred of them!” you might be amazed at how the concept evolves. Cheers! well done.

  34. JON says:

    all you haters are just jealous that you didnt think of it though ;)

  35. Jordan says:

    While the art is no doubt impressive and technically complex, and beautiful to look at, I think there is valid criticism (whoa now, offer a critique of art? Never!) in the resultant sounds that are only tangentially related to the actual sonic vibrations picked up by the needle. I too was hoping for something more random, instead of notes on a major scale. But as someone else pointed out, it’s a reflection of the cultural values of the artist and it would be interesting to see how others choose to interpolate random noise.

  36. Crazy Trevor says:

    I’ve been waiting for this since I was a kid making noise art & now I find out some old log stole my song I’d sue if I was not the Lorcx that speaks for the trees!

  37. Person says:

    Wow. That’s complete bs. Who would actually believe that video? Only dip shuts I guess

  38. hopperodyssey says:

    I want to hear more trees! Love the idea.

    1. Gabe says:

      Trees have to die to make these.

  39. peter griffen says:

    This an awsome example of a good variation of a sound and program that can reach notes from a tree,all the critics are just dumb and basically dont understand any of your findings to be relevent. But this is a very good idea i think and hope you do many more to see differences between different types of trees make various noises just to see what gives off a simple key to symbolise our living world .

  40. [...] Years – Artist Bartholomäus Traubeck figured out a way to play the rings of a tree like a record. The results are rather creepy. (I still say I’d be more impressed if the thing had played “Norwegian Wood.”) (Hat tip to xJane) [...]

  41. Taylor Amerson says:

    An amazing composition… The video is not necessary to appreciate the mastery of the music.

  42. Edward LaHaie says:

    Excellent piece… I applaud your expertise and genius! I guess it would respond to a thin slice of cabbage or other plant or fruit that grows with concentric rings…..

  43. Shaun Puzio says:

    haters gotta hate. this is lush. +1

  44. docta_juice says:

    all the comments seem to be either about how it’s amazing or how it’s total shit. i must say that while this provides zero scientific anything, it is pretty cool. some were expecting science and got art.

    i’ve also seen some hating on the art; saying it’s gimmicky or this and that just because it would be so easy to do. but i think it’s a great work.

    the thing that makes it good art is the fact that nobody else thought to do it first.

  45. Travis says:

    I know its kinda a misleading video, but when i heard it you could almost hear the “strenuous” sections of the trees life. The article stated how the music is that of a horror flick and, in a way, the music represents the “horror” of the trees life. I dont know a ton about trees but im assuming the knots are a stressful period in a trees life, so every time you hear the pounding of the keys its almost as if u can hear the stress of the tree at that point in its life.

    Just enjoy the art the music ppl….everyone knows it doesnt make actual piano sounds

  46. Vivek says:

    Wow…great photography…i love this

  47. I really enjoy this post about play free online games and arcade games in the
    Social Gaming Network

  48. Alice Smart says:

    sorry to say but the attached video is NOT of a tree trunk being ‘played like a record’

  49. doublemer says:

    I ‘d like to hear the songs of a redwood or a sequoia. they have many years of experience and pain to express.

  50. Reblogged this on Matt Knight and commented:
    What an amazing idea, and the execution is fantastic. What a melancholy score.

  51. [...] 5 bloggers like this post. Like this: What would the trunk of a tree sound like if a cross section of it were played like an LP? With his creation Years , Bartholomäus Traubeck attempts to answer that question by using a turntable, PlayStation Eye Camera, a stepper motor to control the arm, and computer running Ableton Live . As you’ll hear in the video above, the rings of the tree trunk, as interpreted by this piece, create an eerie and ominous piano track that sounds like it was taken from psychological horror film. MAKE | Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record – StumbleUpon [...]

  52. Gat Garson says:

    Lovely idea! I like that you created an interpreter that will work with different tree cross-sections. With different steppers you could filter leaves, rocks, wallpaper, anything with texture through a variety of interpreters. Are the sounds triggered by the transitions between light and dark?

    Don’t worry about the haters, noodling around with quirky ideas often leads to something fantastic. Keep on experimenting!

  53. [...] What would the trunk of a tree sound like if a cross section of it were played like an LP? With his creation Years, Bartholomäus Traubeck attempts to answer that question by using a turntable, PlayStation Eye Camera, a stepper motor to control the arm, and computer running Ableton Live. As you’ll hear in the video above, the rings of the tree trunk, as interpreted by this piece, create an eerie and ominous piano track that sounds like it was taken from psychological horror film. Who knew trees were so emo? [Source: Creative Applications Via: Make] [...]

  54. mikey mo says:

    If a tree plays a piano in the forest, and there’s nobody there with a Flash player to hear it, does it make a sound?

  55. [...] MAKE | Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record 12 bloggers like this post. [...]

  56. ChrisW says:

    Please put a ” Warning :Performance art ahead” label on this kind of story so people who don’t appreciate it don’t waste time figuring out that it is BS.

  57. [...] Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record Share this: Pin ItLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. Makers in this post:Robert Howsare [...]

  58. Brex says:

    Very cool dude! Trees and music are both awesome

  59. slygen says:

    All of the people giving crits to the tree-truck playing piano are right, and all of the people bashing the critics are clearly non-musicians and non-technical folk who haven’t a clue how turntables, sound, or music work.

    The article is unclear, plain and simple. The resultant piece is very cool, however the hell it was made.

  60. [...] Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record [...]

  61. [...] Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record [...]

  62. Jay says:

    Could have used major chords – would have sounded a lot less dramatic and a little happier.

  63. Jean Sebastian Bach says:

    pianos are made of trees and they sound more realistic

  64. daisyfaes says:

    Reblogged this on Wild Horses and commented:
    This is amazing…

  65. John Vogel says:

    IMHO the resultant piece of “music” is boring…

  66. Tyler Reeves says:

    When I first started the video I thought it was background music leading up to the actual event of putting the cross section on the turntable. Then when I finished the description I realized it was all interpretation etc. I don’t know why there’s so much negative feedback, did people think that you were going to put a needle on a tree and it would play something awesome? I’d like to hear different instrument interpretations (electric guitar, harp) and also maybe speed up the turntable too during another interpretation.

    All in all I liked it a lot and am pretty darn impressed. Good idea!

  67. Cassie says:

    It was beautiful. Thanks for that.

  68. heather says:

    Wow, surprised how many rude comments were left on this. I found it to be rather interesting and very beautiful. I’m sorry some people can be so rude. Thank you for your video ^_^ I wonder if this was done with another portion of the same tree if it would create the same sound or if it would be different. Assuming the growth pattern isn’t altered by anything it would make sense to sound similar, however with knots and other things happening to the tree i think its fair to say it should be different ^+^

  69. Thats way cool! i wonder what a rock sounds like!

  70. John D Hater says:

    Why are people such assholes to each other online about the simplest things?!!!

  71. Olivia says:

    well at least I think it’s awesome!

  72. Surminga says:

    Ha, thats amazing!

    1. miss Kaz says:

      I love it and think you’re very clever and to get it up and running brilliant, I’d love to see it compared with anything that any of the hatters have done!

  73. Octavio Perez says:

    This is Incredibly remarkable!
    Thank you Matt for sharing this with us.

  74. Tazz says:

    The idea is cool!

    As for the technology…

    1- Given the technology, you can probably convert anything you capture to midi notes. Be it camera or any other type of “capture” device. Hell you can probably convert seismic data to midi. Wonder what a 7 on a Richter scale would sound like? :p
    2- Ableton is reading the midi data and feeding it to a midi instrument. The piano could have been easily changed to a synthesizer and we could of all said it’s electronic music! In fact it’s so damn easy. While receiving midi notes in Ableton you can just cycle through the various instruments on the fly and hear the output directly.
    3- Ableton also provides midi “effects”. This allows Ableton to further analyze the midi notes process them in some sort of way and finally send them to the midi instrument. One such effect is is called the “Scale” effect. You simply tell the plugin convert all notes to a set scale like C Major and voila!

    There’s even Ableton plugins that even correct your playing. So no matter what keys you bash you are corrected to the scale. And now you also know why it’s so damn easy to make music these days.

    1. Tazz says:

      Anyways, I followed all the way to his site and there’s no mention of Ableton. Though he briefly mentions how he programmed a rule set and scale, effectively same as what you can do with Ableton. If he did indeed use Ableton then he spared himself the hassle lol.

      There’s innovators and there’s the rest!

  75. themdg says:

    Anything would sound emo if you only gave it a minor chord to bang away at. Plug this into your wind chime, and it would sound like…well…your wind chime. Peaceful and pleasant.

  76. Forrest says:

    put techno sounds and i bet it would sound like skrylix

  77. la le lu le lo says:

    sad tree is sad :-(

  78. This allows Ableton to further analyze the midi notes process them in some sort of way and finally send them to the midi instrument. One such effect is is called the “Scale” effect. You simply tell the plugin convert all notes to a set scale like C Major and voila!

  79. [...] Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record [...]

  80. [...] Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record [...]

  81. What’s up, the whole thing is going well here and ofcourse every one is sharing information, that’s genuinely
    fine, keep up writing.

  82. Ron Swanson says:

    I survived 12/21/12 woop woop tree songs

  83. [...] Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record [...]

  84. beedashbee says:

    Can someone upload the recording of the original sounds this made? Like the acutal turntable with the cross section of the tree on it? That would be such an amazing thing to compare to the actual piece!

  85. robin says:

    For real, this is a nice share. Thanks Matt

In the Maker Shed