After eight months of building and testing, this weekend, Jarno Smeets flew 100 meters using a set of self-made, flapping wings. The moment he lifts off the ground is pretty amazing. [Thanks, Katie Wilson!]
Update: See the follow up post, about this most likely being a hoax, here.
Gareth Branwyn is a freelancer writer and the former Editorial Director of Maker Media. He is the author or editor of a dozen books on technology, DIY, and geek culture, including the first book about the web (Mosaic Quick Tour) and the Absolute Beginner's Guide to Building Robots. He is currently working on a best-of collection of his writing, called Borg Like Me.
Clearly fake.
What tipped you off?
My amateur analysis (it’s faked) – http://awaitinginspiration.com/2012/03/human-bird-wings
i could be wrong, but it seems like he would need the chest and arms of lou ferrigno and the bone structure of calista flockhart for this to even come close to working.
It’s assisted by the backpack motors and controlled with a Wii controller and an Android phone with attached ADK.
Fancy and perhaps feasible mechanism, check. Stirring music, check. No reason for such an elaborate hoax, check.
So, where’s the cloud of plastic balls hovering under the scrapyard magnet? We SO want it to be real.
But seriously: fabric doesn’t inflate upwards when he leaves the ground, it just flutters around (should be 200lbs of upward pressure on fabric. Imagine forces on a tiny parachute.) Wing lacks swept angle or long counterweight below (or tail elevators on a rear boom), yet never nosedives. Now go look at Snowbird ornithopter on youtube: basic level flight needs much, much higher airspeed with much longer wingspan.
He’s being towed. In each of his videos, you can see the tracks of a vehicle beneath him. He’s basically parasailing with a really fancy wing. It’s neat that it flaps, but I’m sure it doesn’t do anything to help him actually fly.
An impressive mechanism, and I’m sure it’s super fun.
Definitely right. The tracks are just “surprisingly” fresh and in the direction of the flight…
I can’t say I’m convinced that this is legitimate. The flapping mechanism on the website seems like it would require a lot of power to achieve flight. I don’t think a battery would be light enough or last long enough.
faaake….
If you read more about it you will see that it is not human powered.
It has a couple of motors to flap the wings as your arms move
My first thought was this must be fake. Humans do not have the strength to do this. If you do some searching on the website you find the wings are powered by some LiPo batteries and a couple of 2KW electric motors.
And it looks like it’s running on an HTC cell phone with Chipkit running the Android ADK. He uses the cell phone and a Wiimote for controlling the motors.
Correction, it’s a Seeeduino ADK.
It’s motorized… read his blog. The arm flapping controls the mechanism, it doesn’t power it. Still very cool, but unfortunately not human powered.
He just doesn’t seem to be displacing sufficient air rise at the rate he is. He doesn’t have the speed to generate much lift, so it must be entirely due to “flapping”. I’d expect the grass to be swaying and the mics on the cameras to be popping a lot more than they are.
from concept to working prototype in 8 months, i call shenanigans.
also a perfect takeoff and landing on first attempt? never
If there were an Academy Award for Makers, this guy would deserve it.
Arms of lou ferrigno and the bone structure of calista flockhart for this to even come close to working.
He’s obviously being assisted by the uplifting music.
Dont Hate. It was cool looking. I wanna fly.
critical thinking skills != hate
camera always pans away right before and right after flight. Perfect time to switch to cg. Notice the “bones” in the wings right before take off. The the wings at the end of the shot laying on the ground. flat. no bones. It’s a kite attached to him, then edited but really well. Wonder what they are advertising.
This is a (fake) viral video posted by the makers of the GoPro video camera. If you think this is real, go search up some of their previous marketing attempts You folks, of all people, should know better than to get suckered in by this.
Yes it is fake. Video 13/14 “attempted” flight of his is more telling of the video editing / compositing. anyone in video production / animation as I am can tell you it’s fake.
Nice, you guys are posting fake CGI videos now? Take a second to question the authenticity and you’ll hopefully realize that fluid dynamics doesn’t work this way on that scale. The materials and electronics/power side probably doesn’t either. Physics people…physics.
As its totaly clear that this is fake could you pls mark this as a good CGI work and not as a brake through physiks?
I understand that this is easy to belive cause its realy good cgi work but everyone see that this is obviously fake.
Like most people commenting, we know this is a hoax/fake video.
I’ve seen the other videos on youtube and the CGI isn’t really that good. Just watch the wings…. This last video was a little better than the others, but it’s still a fake! Granted, it’s better than I could do, but I don’t have any desire to “pull a fast one” on the world a large.
I feel bad for MAKE, falling for this hoax. MAKE kind of loses some credibility for posting this. I bet it was the “wii-mote” enabled wings premise, at the beginning of the series , wasn’t it…. Those pesky “wii-motes” can make anything seem like a “real hack”…
I am very disappointed that this is (apparently) a very elaborate fake. But it’s true, those wings just aren’t taut enough to be supporting any weight. They should appear as rigid as a parachute.
*sigh*
Don’t believe everything you see on youtube…..
Pingback: lulz | Pearltrees
Compare to high speed footage of birds taking off and you will see the amount of energy and motion needed for flapping lift on a lightweight animal. Obviously this rig doesn’t even come close. http://youtu.be/bSY6UW3hM4Y
Even better, compare to slow motion bat flight. To achieve this flight the operator would have needed a large initial thrust to even get off the ground. Something the video does not provide evidence for.
Pingback: MAKE | ILM Weighs in on Human Birdwings Video
Pingback: ILM Weighs in on Human Birdwings Video | TransAlchemy
Pingback: ILM Weighs in on Human Birdwings Video
FAKE. as any hang-glider pilot would probably tell you, you do not have the strength the keep you leg up and parallel to you body in the air, that’s why all hang-gliders have a little leg/bag harness to lift your legs in the air. How this “pilot” did that at 0:38 is beyond me.
It is,as many people said on here,a hoax.The person who made this appeared on Dutch tv yesterday stating that it was in fact a research into how the media works.
Don’t believe everything you see on youtube…..
Dont Hate. It was cool looking. I wanna fly.
Dont Hate. It was cool looking. I wanna fly.
He’s obviously being assisted by the uplifting music.
Dont Hate. It was cool looking. I wanna fly.
that’s why all hang-gliders have a little leg/bag harness to lift your legs in the air. How this “pilot” did that at 0:38 is beyond me.
The moment lifts off the ground is pretty amazing.
you’re actually a just right webmaster. The site loading speed is amazing. It sort of feels that you’re doing any
distinctive trick. Moreover, The contents are masterwork.
you have performed a fantastic task on this topic!
Pingback: Human Bird Wings | Awaiting Inspiration
send a response cam on to ‘posts in your right as a administrative Computer rằng LA exchange Sắc your Su Li was best job’ of mình.ban as a really good idea.
// What's Trending
Raspberry Pi Design Contest
Seventeen Sneaky Secret Hides
Teardrop Camper Trailer
A Maker Wedding
Dad Builds Son an Iron Man Arc Reactor
What to do with an 800 Lb Eucalyptus Slab
10 Things to Connect to Your Raspberry Pi
Lego Steampunk Strandbeest Model
// What's Shared
A better way to slice a pumpkin
DIY Nerf Darts
100 Dollar Store Organization Ideas for Craft Rooms and Beyond
In the Maker Shed: Minty Boost USB Charger
Mad’s Mouse House
Lace Princess Crowns
I Have a (Puzzling) Dream
Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record
// Most Commented
Plastic Bags into Plastic Blocks: Revisited
10 Hot New Boards to Watch
Why the Maker Movement is Here to Stay
MAKE Asks: Roadside Hacks
DIY Hacks & How To’s: Convert From Battery Power to AC
Ten Tips for Hand Saws and Blades
How To Make Your Own Laundry Detergent
What to do with an 800 Lb Eucalyptus Slab
Trending Topics
Get our Newsletters
About Maker Media
Subscribe
to MAKE!
Get the print and digital versions when you subscribe