I sell filament, so I get asked this question a lot! The answer comes down mainly to understand the different properties of plastic and matching those to your project.
Let’s start with ABS. (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene as it’s known by in it’s hometown) is the grandfather of home FDM filaments.
Print at 210-240º C with a heated bed at 80º C or more.
ABS has a glass transition zone (the temperature that the plastic starts to soften at) of 105º C, and this matters because if you aimed to print something for use in your car, or perhaps a hot-drink coaster you don’t want it to start getting soft and drooping, unless you are aiming for a droopy print.
Due to the nature of the plastic, ABS tends to be very easy to print with from a hot-end point of view – as in it’ll extrude beautifully from most hot-ends without fear of jamming or clogging. However it’s a little more difficult to deal with once it has been extruded, since it loves to shrink as it cools. The shrinkage can cause issues with the part lifting from the bed, or the layers cracking or splitting as the height of the object increases. For this reason it’s an absolute must to print ABS on a heated bed, and preferably within an enclosed-case printer. At the very least, print in a room that’s not too cold and one that is without drafts which might accelerate the cooling and therefore the shrinkage.
ABS can be printed very quickly and is very forgiving of large and/or rapid retraction settings, it resists stringing so very little retraction is usually necessary.
ABS is a rather strong plastic if printed at sufficient temps to get a great layer bond.
ABS has a decent amount of flex to it and it tends to bend rather than snap when put under pressure.
One of the bigger downsides to printing with ABS is the strong smell while it prints. While it doesn’t bother most people, some people may have issues with printing ABS in confined spaces. I would always recommend printing in a well ventilated room no matter what plastic you chose to print with, but I strongly recommend it with ABS. “When in doubt, let the fumes out!” – That’s an old 3d printer’s saying from the 1930’s. Which is of course I totally made up just now.
When to use it:
Objects that might be dropped, put in hot environments or used in a rough manner are perfect uses for ABS. Think of knife handles, car phone mounts, phone cases, toys, wedding rings (mine is black ABS). In short it’s very good for most objects.
When NOT to use it:
If you don’t have a heated bed, forget about it. If you want to print some large objects and don’t have a way of protecting it from breezes or even the ambient air temp, you will fight with splitting and cracking. Avoid ABS if you cannot adequately ventilate the room you’re in, the smell might be irritating.
PLA (Polylactic Acid if you’re asking for it on the street) is the sweet smelling hippy cousin to ABS – IT BIODEGRADES AND SMELLS LIKE CANDY WHEN YOU PRINT! If that fact alone doesn’t interest you, then read on.
Print at 180 – 200º C and while you can print without a heated bed, I recommend one running at 60º C
PLA’s glass transition temp is probably it’s biggest downside and at only 60ishº (yes that’s a scientific value) it limits how you can use this plastic. Forget about making a gear-shift knob for your car, unless you like shifting with a gummy bear… Which is actually an awesome idea.
In almost the complete opposite to ABS, PLA users sometimes have difficulties with jamming in the hot-end (especially all-metal hot end users) due to the sticky and expanding nature of PLA as it melts. This doesn’t mean you should shy away from printing with it, just a drop of oil added to almost any hot-end when you put a roll on will give you smooth, jam-free, jam-smelling prints till the cows come home.
The real joy with PLA comes as it lays on the print bed. With almost no shrinkage, you can print massive prints in open framed printers with little fear of lifting from the bed, warping or cracking, it’s a great filament to use when showing off your printer in a public setting.
Did I mention that I love how it smells?
While you can still print incredibly strong objects with PLA, it tends to be a little more brittle than other plastics. Rather than bouncing when dropped or struck, some printed parts may just shatter or chip. Thin parts are more likely to snap than bend very far.
Layer bond is very strong if printed appropriately.
I’m not advocating the deliberate inhalation of PLA fumes at all (I’m sure there’s a lawsuit there somewhere), however if you do happen to catch a whiff of PLA as it prints, I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised. A day of printing in PLA makes my office smell lovely and kind of makes me hungry. The fumes are minor, and they smell good!
When to use it:
Personally I recommend using it whenever you can. It’s a bioplastic that can be recycled or composted. It’s perfect for boxes, gifts, models, prototype parts. Oh and don’t be afraid of using it outdoors, while it does biodegrade, it does need a heated composting setup and it’s insoluble in water, so make a PLA garden gnome right now!
When to avoid it:
If you’re making something that needs to hold up in 60º (C) temperatures avoid PLA, it will start sagging at this temperature. Due to it’s brittle nature it isn’t recommended for tool handles or parts that will be dropped repeatedly, also parts that have very thin portions will break after bending slightly.
It’s worthwhile learning to use both materials since both ABS and PLA have ideal use situations. Myself, I try to use PLA at every opportunity due to it’s biodegradable qualities, ease of printing and sweet smells :) but ABS is just the ticket for higher impact or higher temperature jobs.
Thanks for reading, leave a comment if you’d like to have other topics covered!
22 thoughts on “ABS or PLA? Choosing The Right Filament”
I’ve read a post about that PLA might be stronger but I think it all depends on the printing process. But let’s make it clear: injection moulded ABS is way much stringer than PLA stuff, interesting thoughts anyway: http://3dfizzr.wordpress.com/2013/07/10/some-facts-about-the-most-common-3d-printing-materials-pla-vs-abs/
Though trail and error, I have found that my ABS robot brackets are stronger and tougher then the same brackets printed in PLA. It all comes down to layer adhesion along the z-axis. If you get good adhesion between layers then ABS is hard to beat.
It’s a tough call since ‘stronger’ is dependent on the type of stress the object is under… Generally ABS is more durable, though both are incredibly strong if used correctly.
Uh, what are the units on your degrees?
Well, considering the inside of a hot car is going to be a lot higher than 60-80 degrees fahrenheit, I would say celsius.
That would be my guess, but I was asking for the actual answer, not another guess.
They are in Celsius. Most if not all 3D printers and 3D printer documentation is done in SI (metric, MM and Celsius)
SI-unit would actually be Kelvin ;)
I tried to print at 240K but it didn’t work at all.
Sorry! Should have mentioned it was all Celsius!
Thank you for the confirm! It would be best to update the article with the units, but thanks for responding!
after every mention of a teperature, it says C , that means Celsius.
This year I have made 64,000 dollars so far with my computer and I am a university student . I am linked with a business entity that outsource online jobs . I heard about it previous year and I have made a great cash . It is really user friendly and I am just so happy to have that opportunity …..
Odd, when I read this it had bare numbers, no units at all. Must have been a rendering problem at the time (maybe my browser). Sorry for the confusion … and not logging into disqus for over 2 months.
Reblogged this on Arcanus's Random Stuffs.
I don’t care what plastic you print in, all bets are off when your trying to make anything out of plastic for use inside a car. You take a car with a black interior in the summer sun and the dashboard gets hot enough to cause warping in a lot of plastic. The auto companies use special plastic formulations for their stuff and I have seen ABS cell phone holders warp right next to vent louvers that are clearly also made of ABS and are unaffected.
Great writeup, thanks a lot!
It’s possible to even get the tournament in the match through the use of this hack.
Thanks for sharing such a nice opinion, post is nice, thats why i
have read it completely
ABS is so hard to print well on an open printer, I’ve started using PET-G and never looked back. It has similar melt temp to ABS, really low moisture absorbtion, sticks to bed well and is very strong, Layer Adhesion is impressive. Main drawbacks are lack of color and untill recently was only available in transparent/Translucent, but now is available in Black and White and a few other colors are starting to be available
You mentioned adding a drop of oil to keep PLA from jamming the hot end. What kind of oil?
Comments are closed.