Is The New Raspberry Pi 2 Camera Shy?

Raspberry Pi
Is The New Raspberry Pi 2 Camera Shy?
The new Raspberry Pi 2 with the problem SMPS chip (labelled U16) circled.
The new Raspberry Pi 2 with the problem SMPS chip (labelled U16) shown.

Bright bursts of light are causing the new Pi to shut off.

If you want to take pictures of your new Pi, don’t use a flash. Or if you must, don’t use a Xenon flash, or just stick a blob of Blu-Tack over the power supply if you want to keep your Pi running during its close up.

The new Raspberry Pi 2 was just announced a week ago, and before that the number of boards in circulation, at least outside of the Foundation, was obviously going to be very limited. I only got my hands on it about a week or so before the release when I went to the Foundation’s offices to interview Eben Upton — the founder of the Raspberry Pi Foundation, and now CEO of the Raspberry Pi trading company — about the board.

While that’s only to be expected, the limited number of people with their hands on real hardware means that there is obviously the chance of undiscovered problems, and sometimes those turn out to be pretty weird. It’s certainly the case this time—as the new Raspberry Pi 2 is camera shy.

The problem was first discovered when an owner attempted to take some flash photographs of the new board and found that taking its picture caused the board to instantly power off.

“This isn’t something we’ve come across before. Flash photography wasn’t in the test program for Pi 2.” — Eben Upton, CEO at Raspberry Pi

The problem is caused by the switched mode power supply (SMPS) chip on the board, labelled U16 on the silkscreen, which appears to be photosensitive. Too much light causes fluctuation in the power supply and the board resets.

“Honestly, if I had to pick one bug to find in Pi 2 at this stage, an excessive sensitivity to paparazzi would probably be it.” — Eben Upton, CEO at Raspberry Pi

It’s definitely a photoelectric effect, and is due to an encapsulation problem with the chip — optically masking the top of the problem chip makes the problem go away. Now this sort of problem isn’t unknown, there was incident where the Halon fire suppression system was triggered in a nuclear power plant when an engineer was taking pictures of the control panel, and can be easily fixed in future production runs.

A close up of the problem SMPS chip (labelled U16).
A close up of the problem SMPS chip (labelled U16).

Update: After spending most of the day with the new Raspberry Pi 2 and bright flashes of light, the Raspberry Pi team passes on the news that your Pi should suffer from no permanent damage from the power drop out problem — although the resulting crash might cause corruption on the SD Card.

Oscilloscope trace of the voltage level when you trigger xenon flash towards the Raspberry Pi 2. (Credit: Raspberry Pi Foundation)
Oscilloscope trace of the voltage level when you trigger xenon flash towards the Raspberry Pi 2. (Credit: Raspberry Pi Foundation)

Liz Upton — the Head of Communications at the Raspberry Pi Foundation — also goes into a lot of detail about the physics behind issue and goes out of her way to reassure us all that this is a hard bug to trigger.

“…common everyday light sources – e.g. bright sunlight, indoor lighting, angry cyclists – don’t cause this to happen, so please don’t worry!”  — Liz Upton, the Head of Communication, Raspberry Pi

The team is also looking into possible ways to make future production Pis immune to the issue.

19 thoughts on “Is The New Raspberry Pi 2 Camera Shy?

  1. Is The New Raspberry Pi 2 Camera Shy? | Raspberry World says:

    […] By Alasdair Allan […]

  2. david d says:

    Silicon is transparent to IR. Xenon flash tubes emit a significant amount of IR along with the visible light used for taking photos.

  3. gabrielstuff says:

    Is it same on Rapsberry 1 ?

    1. jan kaptijn says:

      no it isn’t

  4. rgalate says:

    Video or it didn’t happen!

  5. Aristarco Palacios says:

    Wouldn’t electrical tape have the same masking effect as Blu-Tack?

    1. Alasdair Allan says:

      Should work fine. Anything that opaque to photons should do it…

      1. Phil says:

        Sorry Alastdair, its not quite what you’d expect… the typical black plastic electrical tape is typically transparent to IR – we used to take pictures of boards in racks with IR cameras to see heat spots, but you need airflow to be there to be realistic, open fronts spoil results…use black plastic electrical tape you can close the hole, get regular airflow and still have the camera see inside for IR results.

  6. clave says:

    I remember a lot of klystron-based high-power UHF TV transmitters that had arc detectors in their final two cavities, and they’d shut down the tube if someone was carelessly taking flash photos. It was an effective way for a nimrod to inadvertently put a station off the air for a few minutes.

  7. 1p – Is the New Raspberry Pi 2 Camera Shy? – Exploding Ads says:
  8. 1p – Is the New Raspberry Pi 2 Camera Shy? – blog.offeryour.com says:
  9. Maker Pro News: RadioShack Bankrupt, RasPi 2 camera shy, and more | Make: says:

    […] As we noted last week, the Raspberry Pi 2, Model B is finally available for pre-order and a lucky few have had a chance to goof around with them. Some early users, though, noticed a glitch: The Pi 2 is camera shy. […]

  10. Blue Coaster33 says:

    Healing’s Dragon

    to search out troubles to further improve my web site!I suppose its alright to generate use of some of your concepts!!

  11. streaming movies says:

    Third Flower

    My wife and that i are already now delighted that Albert could carry out his scientific studies because of the concepts he had by your website. It really is once in a while perplexing to only usually be giving freely ways which a number of people might…

  12. stream movies says:

    The Ships’s Voyages

    I believe engineering just makes it worse. Now there is a channel to hardly ever treatment, now there is not going to become a probability for them to find out.

  13. stream movies says:

    The Absent Game

    Concerning me and my husband we have owned much more MP3 players over the years than I can count, together with Sansas, iRivers, iPods (basic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few decades I’ve settled down to one line of gamers.

  14. U16拡大写真 – OnBoard PRESS Japan says:

    […] via Is The New Raspberry Pi 2 Camera Shy? | Make: […]

  15. The new Raspberry Pi 3 — With Wi-Fi and Bluetooth | Make: says:

    […] camera-shy Raspberry Pi 2 suffered problems with the switched mode power supply (SMPS) chip on the board, which turned out […]

Comments are closed.

Tagged

Alasdair Allan is a scientist, author, hacker and tinkerer, who is spending a lot of his time thinking about the Internet of Things. In the past he has mesh networked the Moscone Center, caused a U.S. Senate hearing, and contributed to the detection of what was—at the time—the most distant object yet discovered.

View more articles by Alasdair Allan
FEEDBACK