Kid’s Kitchen: Heart-Shaped Homemade Pepperoni Pizza

Craft & Design Food & Beverage

In the Kitchen

By Katie Goodman
Personal pan pizzas are so fun for kids to help prepare. Even more so when you form them into hearts for Valentine’s Day. Heart-shaped pizza crusts, heart-healthy homemade pizza sauce, and heart-shaped pepperoni – awesome!
You can adapt this recipe for many other holidays using cookie cutters. I love to purchase graduated sets of different shapes, so we can do many fun things in different sizes. Not only are shapes great for presentation, but they also create great teaching moments and are fun for children to help with.
Some of our favorite shapes are hearts, snowflakes, and flowers, but you can purchase many other shapes in craft stores or online.
If you don’t already have a favorite pizza crust recipe, we really enjoy these:

The great thing about the Light Whole Wheat Recipe is the method. You prepare 4 pounds of dough in advance, store it in the refrigerator, and take out dough as needed throughout the next two weeks. That way, when you are ready to make pizza, there is no 2-hour rise time to wait for.
The Pizza Dough with Oregano is delicious as well, but has a more traditional preparation and will need to be planned for in advance, which, as most parents know, is not always an option.

Download PDF Download the Recipe PDF
Right click to save the PDF to your desktop. Directions on downloading PDFs.


For the Homemade Pizza Sauce:
6 oz tomato paste
1 cup crushed tomatoes
1 tbsp olive oil
2 tsp dried Italian seasoning
1/4 tsp salt
1/8 tsp black pepper
1/2 tsp granulated sugar

For the Pizzas:
1 lb of your favorite pizza dough
Fresh mozzarella cheese, grated – about 8 oz
All-natural pepperoni slices
Homemade Pizza Sauce


1″ heart cookie cutter
4 1/2″ – 6″ heart cookie cutter
Pizza stone or cookie sheet
Flour for dusting
Parchment paper


Step 1: Preheat the oven to 550 degrees F (or 500 if that is the highest your oven goes). Place a pizza stone or large, rectangular cookie sheet on the top middle rack during the preheat.

Step 2:
Add the tomato paste, crushed tomatoes, olive oil, dried Italian seasoning, salt, black pepper, and sugar to a medium-sized sauce pan.
Tip: If you don’t have crushed tomatoes, you can puree a can of diced tomatoes in a small food processor or blender.
Step 3: Whisk the ingredients to combine and cook over medium heat until it begins to sputter. Then turn to low and let simmer while you prepare the pizza crusts, pepperoni, and cheese.
Step 4: Use the small cookie cutter to cut out hearts from the pepperoni slices and set aside. I like to use the heart cutouts and the slices with heart “windows” in them so there is no waste. Set aside.
Step 5: Roll out a piece of parchment paper large enough to roll the pizza dough out on (plus a little extra). Lightly dust with flour. Add the pizza dough, dusting the top lightly with flour, and pat it into a flat round.
Step 6: Using a rolling pin, roll the dough out into 1/4″ to 1/8″ thickness (depending on your crust preference). Using the large cookie cutter, cut out 4-6 individual-sized pizza crusts from the dough.
Step 7: Remove the scraps from around the pizzas and re-roll to form additional crusts. You can also form breadsticks for dipping in sauce with the scrap dough, or store it in the refrigerator for later use.
Step 8: Spread 1-2 tablespoons of sauce on top of each crust. Then sprinkle with cheese and top with pepperoni.
Step 9: Transfer the entire sheet of parchment with the crusts on it onto your pizza stone or cookie sheet. Bake at 550 degrees F for 5-10 minutes.
Extra sauce will store well in an airtight container refrigerated for up to a week, or a month in the freezer.
About the Author:
Katie Goodman blogs at goodLife {eats} where she shares what she finds good in the kitchen and in life through recipes, family memories, and yummy photography. She also works as a freelance food writer and photographer for various sites. Outside of cooking, Katie loves reading, gardening, visiting family, and attending the Balloon Fiesta in Albuquerque, New Mexico, where she resides with her husband and two children.

25 thoughts on “Kid’s Kitchen: Heart-Shaped Homemade Pepperoni Pizza

  1. says:

    So very cute!

  2. Paula says:

    Awww I love it! This is so cute. I am so gonna make one of these some day! Maybe that would be great for my mom on mother’s day. She would be so happy!

  3. Phô mai que says:

    Looks so yummy! This weekend I am going to try this for my kids. Thank you for the recipe, Katie!

  4. Kid Friendly Valentine's Day Menu Ideas | Over The Big Moon says:

    […]  If you’ve never made homemade pizza, Make Craft has an awesome step by step tutorial here!  I will also make my super easy and amazing breadstick recipe that I shared HERE! […]

  5. Weekend Wrap-Up | says:

    […] hikes for every woman who are on my to do list. I know what we are making on Valentine’s Day. The Milky Way always takes my breath away. Even with the best […]

  6. Valentine’s Day Meals | Cassidy Alyse says:

    […] Heart Shaped Pizza source […]

  7. Why I Love Valentine’s Day and 10 Fun Ideas That Will Make You Love It Too! | Homefront United Network says:

    […] Heart-Shaped Homemade Pepperoni Pizza – kid friendly adorable mini heart pizzas. Perfect for dinner and if you’re like me – you’d substitute ready-made pizza dough and sauce to make it even easier! […]

  8. Valentines Fun! says:

    […] lunch I am thinking these pizzas I love the heart shaped crust and the […]

  9. DANNABELLA says:

    […] Heart-Shaped Pepperoni Pizzas […]

  10. Valentine’s Ideas | threat level GINGER says:

    […] I loved the idea of a heart shaped pizza! If you want to do it all from scratch find the full ingredients and directions here. […]

  11. Valentine's Day Recipes | Love to be in the Kitchen says:

    […] Heart Shaped Pizza with Heart Shaped Pepperoni from Makezine […]

  12. Think Outside the (Chocolate) Box This Valentine’s Day | Baltimore Collegetown Network says:

    […] I <3 Pizza  […]

  13. walentynkowy posiłek | Polskie Rękodzieło says:

    […] czas na pizze […]

  14. Cheap Pizza Recipes New York Style | Pizza Cooking says:

    […] A: never forget to smile. No matter is that they may not necessarily have the gift in December and discussions to benefit of the amino acid and so are raisins and amino acids increase sperm can […]

  15. Escuela Infantil GRANVIA Vistahermosa » Archivo del weblog 5 recetas fáciles para San Valentín - Escuela Infantil GRANVIA Vistahermosa says:

    […] Fuente: Makenzine […]

  16. Escuela Infantil GRANVIA » Archivo del weblog 5 recetas fáciles para San Valentín - Escuela Infantil GRANVIA says:

    […] Fuente: Makenzine […]

  17. 20 Super Sweet Valentine's Day Treats - Sunshine Whispers says:

    […] Heart-Shaped Homemade Pepperoni Pizzas from Makezine: […]

  18. Valentijn lunch recepten: de lekkerste - Like & Love (it!) says:

    […] 2. Voor de warme lunch: een hartjespizza. […]

  19. 101 Ideas for Valentine's Day - Meet Penny says:

    […] Heart Shaped Homemade Pizza from Make […]

  20. Valentines day recipes | The Chic Geek says:

    […] […]

  21. Kid Friendly Valentine's Day Activities - In The ZONA says:

    […] Something to eat: Heart-Shaped Homemade Pizza […]

  22. 10 Creative and Delicious Valentine’s Day Ideas | The Hip Mothership says:

    […] kids love to make their own pizzas, so this Valentine’s Day we are going to make our own heart shaped pizzas with heart shaped pepperoni. How fun is […]

  23. 17 Cookie Cutter Hacks Will Change The Way You Cook Forever - OMG says:

    […] Source: Source: […]

  24. Homemade Pepperoni Pizza | Shake that bacon says:

    […] Full recipe on : makezine […]

  25. 18 Cookie Cutter Hacks That Will Take Your Life to the Next Level - DON'T POKE THIS BEAR says:

    […] (source) […]

Comments are closed.

Discuss this article with the rest of the community on our Discord server!


Maker Faire Bay Area 2023 - Mare Island, CA

Escape to an island of imagination + innovation as Maker Faire Bay Area returns for its 15th iteration!

Buy Tickets today! SAVE 15% and lock-in your preferred date(s).