There is a rather large gender gap in the makerspace community; one that has mirrored the well-documented gaps in various STEM fields, and while some proactive spaces have increased their efforts to support inclusivity, it has proven to be an uphill battle for others. It’s achievable though, with many examples (such as Artisan’s Asylum welding courses and the existence of Double Union) that show signs of the maker community championing incredible initiatives. I’m glad to see that the latter is the case for current Pumping Station: One member Erica Tesla.
Her post “6 Women Who Need Makerspaces (Including Me)” over at xojane covers the core essentials that makerspaces tackle in order to deliver a positive and inclusive maker experience, while touching on a few of the more intangible facets that turn first-time visitors into lifelong makers. While the title hints that the focal point is a listicle of individual archetypes, it’s honestly more about the components that make a community effective to a wide variety of makers. It’s one thing to have a core set of enthusiasts in your space and the tools to keep them there, but it helps to have members that actively display enthusiasm for those looking to expand their horizons. That behavior should always be encouraged:
Nobody’s going to judge you for your newfound obsession with molecular gastronomy — the people who frequent makerspaces just want to be around others who unironically like stuff. In a way it’s like the opposite of the Internet — no hate in the comments.
Erica’s experience at her local makerspace focused on a strong orientation process, one that offers empowerment to new members to contribute to problem solving, instead of assuming the status quo:
The space I’m a member of actually tells prospective members during orientation: “If you can undo in it in less than four hours, don’t ask permission, just do it.” I gather dudes get that sort of advice all along, but we don’t; it’s liberating and confidence-building.
Personally, as a founding member and former Board member of Pumping Station: One, I find it encouraging that years later the space I once called home has marched forward. They’ve taken the proactive steps necessary to improve their onboarding experience, and have worked to make their space more inclusive to a wonderfully diverse community. I can personally vouch that this was one of our weaknesses back in 2009. For years keeping the lights on was the priority, and our small band of 30 members were close but consequently less approachable to new folks. I’d categorize our early attempts at membership as hectic, inconsistent, and full of what Erica labels as “a lot of testosterone and at least a dozen glorious beards.” I credit the efforts of former Pumping Station: One presidents Anne Petersen and Bryanna Denney for not just prioritizing efforts to better equip new members, but tirelessly pushing to ensure a safe and inclusive environment for everyone. At 372 members as of January 2015, it’s clear that the Board of Directors have done something right.
However there’s still plenty room for improvement for makerspace recruitment. While it’s safe to say that the majority of our readership has at least a passing knowledge of makerspaces, many organizations are still relying on mere word-of-mouth advertising. Don’t believe me? Check the comments at the bottom of the linked article and you’ll see firsthand the growing excitement from an entirely new set of makers who are excited by the prospect of cultivating their interests. That’s great. It’s still new to somebody — and that’s exactly why we put the hours into a makerspace in the first place. New perspectives and backgrounds enrich communities with different skill sets and collectively grow the group’s knowledge base. Having the framework to bring new members from a variety of backgrounds to your makerspace ensures long-term success.
Don’t misjudge though; the efforts of inclusivity are far from solved. What we see here from Erica Tesla is the sign of an ongoing process, one that takes time but thankfully show signs of moving forward. I’m happy to see progress; even if it’s one person at a time.
What about your makerspace? What has your community done to reach out to a more diverse membership? Perhaps your space has always been inclusive; what efforts do you think contributed to that? What failed? Let me know in the comments!
4 thoughts on “Why It’s Good for Everyone When Your Makerspace Is More Inclusive”
Chicago’s Pumping Station: One IS my makerspace. They’ve come a long way – and they’ve definitely grown since I found out about them a couple of years ago.
Reblogged this on Arcanus's Random Stuffs.
Vocademy The Makerspace in Riverside,CA has a membership base with over 40% women. We have what has become something of a mantra there that says the tools of makers don’t care what gender, race, creed, orientation, or social class you are. It’s all about skills that ANYBODY can learn.
Reblogged this on heavydiy and commented:
Let’s be honest. We nerds some times get all uppity when new people come into what we believe is OUR space. It’s made even worse when a small but poorly socialized and vocal minority who are in reality scared and intimated by women act very hostile toward them, as the pervasive assholeness toward women present in nearly any virtual space illustrates.
That bullshit needs to stop.
Great piece, Jim! <3
If Makerspaces are all about teaching people how to make stuff, why *wouldn’t* you have a policy of trying to include folks who would not normally be doing that sort of thing?
You never know what someone can accomplish, until you give them the tools and help them get started. Inclusiveness makes sense from a practical and mission point of view (aside from just generally being a great idea).
At my work, a Design company, several of us got together and bought a bunch of Arduinos, then offered a class on how to use them to all comers. We have some very bright people here, but they’re not all electrical/programmer types. Just having the opportunity to play with the Arduino (they got to keep them) with someone knowledgeable looking over their shoulders was all it took.
Comments are closed.